Close

A Different Way Of Looking At Car Resale Value

If you live in Kenya, you are definitely familiar with the idea of car resale value, which is a huge part of the Kenyan car buying experience. A significant part of the car owning population buys second hand imports from Japan (typically 5-7 years old), with a view of driving it for may be 3-6 years, then replacing it with a newer second hand car.

Typically, Toyotas are beloved because they have a higher resale value, and as a result, they also tend to be more expensive than most of the other models.

Now, I’ve been thinking of disposing my Mitsubishi which has served me faithfully for 6 years now. In the open market, it is worth 50-60% of what I bought it for, which isn’t unreasonable when you consider depreciation, but a Toyota would be worth may be 85% of its purchase value. Here’s how I’ve worked this out: I bought my Mitsubishi station wagon for 700,000 bob in 2009. At that time, an equivalent station wagon (Toyota Fielder) of a similar age and with the extras my car has was going for 1.2 million shillings. Today, my car resale value is between 350,000 – 400,000 bob, I figure the Fielder would go for 1 million bob maximum.

At face value, if I had 1.2 million shillings in 2009, which would be a better car to buy? All things held constant, the Fielder looks like the obvious choice.

But is it?

Let’s talk opportunity cost. By spending 500,000 bob more on a car, I am forgoing returns I would make if I invested that money elsewhere, and just went for the cheaper car.

I did a quick back of the envelope calculation of 500,000, invested in a corporate bond (for example), that is paying a conservative 13.5% annually in returns.  The table below shows the interest earned, and the cumulative interest over time.

Interest earned

This means that if I had invested the extra cash and I sold my car today,my bank account will have a total of  1,418,920 shillings (350,000 car sale + 568,920 interest + 500,000 principal).

The Toyota person will have 1 million shillings from the sale of his/her car.

Of course there are other considerations in the car buying decision like fuel efficiency, maintenance, utility and ego, but I thought it’s interesting that we never consider the opportunity cost of buying an expensive car which has a high resale value.  I also did not consider it, I just bought the car I could afford 😀

Share

About the Author

The aim of this blog is to simplify personal finance.
If you have questions or would like to get in touch with me, leave your details on the form below, and I will get in touch. Thanks for reading.

2 Comments